You are on a collision course and the ship should give way. What do you do?
You are on a collision course and the ship should give way. When is the right time to alter course?
James Stevens answers your Questions of Seamanship.
Question: When is the right time to alter course?
Roy owns Boreas, a 12m long-keeled Bermudan cutter.
He bought her because, in his words, she is sea-kindly and stable.
The downside is that Boreas is heavy, difficult to manoeuvre and slow in open seas.
Roy and wife Peggy are sailing from Cherbourg to the Solent.
The wind is northwesterly 4 and Boreas is sailing close- hauled on a port tack at about 4 to 5 knots in good visibility in daylight.
Roy has safely negotiated the shipping off Cherbourg and is now in clear water, north of the Traffic Separation Schemes and about 10 miles from the Isle of Wight.
A small coaster appears on the port bow.
Roy takes bearings of it with the hand- bearing compass.
Predicting navigational hazards
Jonty Pearce gives a thorough breakdown of how to avoid other ships at sea, from tankers to trawlers
Cruising after Brexit and sailing in Europe
As Europe begins to open up again for cruising, Lu Heikell looks at the implications of Brexit on UK sailors…
How to avoid collisions in fog
Not many of us would happily set sail in fog but sometimes it is unavoidable, and knowing how to avoid…
Why you should keep a lookout with your ears
There’s a simple way to enhance your watchkeeping abilities, as Colregs Rule 5 obliges every skipper to do. Andy Du…
How to sail to France from the UK
For home-waters sailors who are considering a holiday cruise to France, Ken Endean looks at the options for making a…
The bearings remain constant. Roy knows that in the open sea the coaster should keep clear.
As an additional precaution, Roy has hoisted the octahedral radar reflector so he feels confident that he is visible.
Roy holds his course – he doesn’t want to alter his heading and confuse the coaster which is now less than a mile off.
The two vessels continue on a collision course; Roy decides to tack.
He instructs Peggy to put the helm over and concentrates on the jib and staysail sheets.
In the meantime, the ship has altered course to starboard and is now heading straight for Boreas.
The yacht scrapes the side of the ship, fortunately without serious damage except for a very shaken crew.
What should Roy have done?
James Stevens answers:
Roy is correct in thinking that the coaster should keep clear outside of the Traffic Separation Schemes.
The captain of the coaster also knew that and made the correct alteration of course, to starboard.
The problem is that it all happened too late.
First, it is a good rule of thumb that yachts should, if possible, avoid a situation where a ship is the give way vessel.
This means making a very early decision to tack or bear away and find a large gap in the shipping lane.
Continuing on a course across the bow of a ship is obviously hazardous.
In this situation, once Boreas was within a mile of the ship, the safest action would have been to bear away and sail parallel to the ship’s course.
This would have given Roy time to work out what the ship was doing and to avoid a collision.
A turn to port in a potential collision situation with a ship is always more hazardous than a turn to starboard.
Roy also took his eye off the ship at the vital moment.
The coaster took the right action but it should have been earlier and more positive to avoid a collision as required by Rule 8 of the International Regulations for Preventing Collisions at Sea.
Collisions between yachts and ships are very rare, particularly in good visibility.
This question is based on a real incident which happened in the Channel 30 years ago.
Enjoyed reading this?
You can save money by taking out a subscription to Yachting Monthly magazine.
Subscriptions cost less than the cover price and are available in both print and digital editions through our official online shop Magazines Direct. All postage and delivery costs are included.
Click here to find your nearest shop selling Yachting Monthly
- Yachting Monthly is packed with all the information you need to help you get the most from your time on the water.
- Take your seamanship to the next level with tips, advice and skills from our expert skippers and sailors
- Impartial in-depth reviews of the latest yachts and equipment will ensure you buy the best whatever your budget
- If you are looking to cruise away with friends Yachting Monthly will give you plenty of ideas of where to sail and anchor
For all the latest from the sailing world, follow our social media channels Facebook, Twitter and Instagram.