After losing his beloved Harrier of Down in the North Sea, Julian Mustoe tells Yachting Monthly 'What the future holds for me, I do not know'

Julian Mustoe: ‘I’m shipwrecked, homeless and nearly destitute’

On the morning of Saturday 3 October 2015 the marine weather forecast was favourable. I was at last free to sail aboard Harrier from the Shetland Islands to Bergen in Norway, 200 miles away. My travelling plan was to spend the summer of 2016 in the Baltic Sea while I visited many of the cities and towns associated with the medieval Hanseatic League. Perhaps another book would emerge.

Help Julian fight homelessness

Julian’s friends have created a JustGiving website to raise funds from the yachting community and wider world to help him get back on his feet.
JustGiving Website:
https://crowdfunding.justgiving.com/harrierappeal

To begin with all went well. During Sunday a sailing breeze from the southwest carried me eastward in good style. Monday brought unexpectedly calm conditions. The sea was tranquil, the sails flapped idly and the autumn sun was warm to the skin. During the following night the wind returned, but not from a favourable direction nor with a comfortable strength. It came in from the east and it soon increased to force 7-8, a near gale. Harrier cannot make progress against such a wind. I hove-to to wait until the forecast wind should return. Harrier lay quietly under a fully reefed mainsail as the three and four metre waves rolled past to the west.

Julian Mustoe

Both Julian and Harrier of Down were weathering the conditions well until disaster struck

At dawn the next day the strong contrary wind continued to blow beneath a heavy grey sky. I could not receive additional radio weather forecasts in the middle of the North Sea. Aboard Harrier I carried a three metre diameter parachute type sea anchor, together with a heavy nylon warp 100 metres long. I therefore deployed the sea anchor and settled down to await a change in the weather. That night life on board was uncomfortable and wet, but not dangerous.

Julian Mustoe

A hefty stainless steel fitting connecting the tiller to the rudder stock snapped, leaving Harrier helpless

The next day, Wednesday, something went wrong with our motion in the seas. I quickly found that the steering gear had failed. The tiller on Harrier is connected to the rudder stock by means of a hefty block of stainless steel, weighing about a kilo. The top of the stock was bolted to the stainless block through a tightly fitting vertical splined hole. The entire stainless steel block had split into two pieces along the line of the rudder stock hole. Harrier’s rudder could not be used, it was now impossible to steer the yacht and no improvised repair was possible. I had to be towed back to harbour. The disintegration of a solid lump of stainless steel was the very last equipment failure that I had anticipated.

The failure of the steering gear had nothing to do with the bad weather, and it could have happened just as easily to a large fully crewed yacht as to Harrier and me.

Most parts of the North Sea are quite heavily trafficked. I radioed an oil industry patrol ship, the Prospector, and asked them to enquire if the Shetland lifeboat could come out nearly 100 miles and tow me back to Lerwick. The message was taken by the Lerwick coastguard who assumed that my situation was dire, and they proposed to send out a rescue helicopter. Via Prospector I was able to reply that I needed a tow but that I did not need to be rescued from the air. Lerwick responded by asking the Norwegian coastguard service to come out and fetch me.

During the night Harrier continued to drift downwind in safety but not under control. On the horizon downwind I could see bright lights of the Alwyn North gas platform. Gas platforms are dangerous places, where highly volatile and inflammable materials are recovered and processed. There was some anxiety aboard Alwyn North that Harrier might collide with them. However, I could see that we would drift near but not onto the platform. In the event we passed about two miles clear and out into unencumbered waters.

Julian Mustoe

The Norwegian patrol boat Bergen raced out 100 miles to take Julian onboard and Harrier in tow

At dawn on Thursday a Norwegian patrol boat, the KV Bergen, was in sight. She offered to tow me to Norway provided only that I left Harrier and came aboard the ship. I scrambled onto their RIB and was taken to the ship. Harrier was attached by a long warp astern and the tow began, in apparently good order, towards the coast of Norway rather less than 100 miles away. Harrier was floating buoyantly astern and the ship was steaming ahead at a modest five knots. The Norwegian government had sent a modern, fully manned and superbly equipped ship out into the ocean just to bring help to a sole British yachtsman. Once aboard the KV Bergen I realised that I was exhausted and that I was feeling somewhat battered. I got into a bunk and fell into a deep sleep, confident that all would be well.

Julian Mustoe

Julian was awoken to find Harrier foundering. Shortly after this photo was taken, her towline nsapped and she was gone

When, in late afternoon, I awoke I was told that Harrier was sinking. What?! She had been taking on water and was now towing astern in a half-submerged condition. I went to the ship’s bridge from which I could see my lovely little boat struggling for her life. Slowly she sank lower into the water. One last time her bow came up out of the water, as if she were gasping for breath. Then her hull slipped beneath the surface, her mast sank into the water, the tow rope snapped and Harrier disappeared from sight for ever.

I felt as if I was watching an old friend drown.

I do not know what went wrong. Harrier was a strong boat and she should have towed successfully for hundreds of miles. Did a window fail and admit water? Was she damaged by striking an obstruction in the water? Whatever was the cause she was gone, and with her most of my possessions and much of my small amount of money sank to the bottom of the North Sea. Without Harrier I was homeless, nearly destitute and a shipwrecked sailor.

Julian Mustoe

Julian arrived in Bergen grateful for his rescue and heartbroken for his loss: ‘Life will not be the same again’

Next day, Friday 9 October, the KV Bergen docked in the city of Bergen. The following day I flew to London and cast myself into the arms of generous friends. Life will not be the same again, but just what the future holds for me I do not know.

Help Julian fight homelessness

Julian’s friends have created a JustGiving website to raise funds from the yachting community and wider world to help him get back on his feet.
https://crowdfunding.justgiving.com/harrierappeal

Harrier has been Julian’s home and life for the past 15 years. His remarkable book, The Voyage of the Harrier about his world voyage in the wake of Darwin’s Beagle has received critical acclaim and is available on Amazon world wide. Now Harrier is lost, Julian has no home and has lost all his possessions. This is a terrible blow for a remarkable and courageous man.

The Voyage of the Harrier is available here

  • Donald Smith

    I`d be raving mad at captain and crew of Norwegian KV Bergen and seeking answers as to why they kept on towing a sinking ship even so much as to snap her toe line. The picture is evidence enough showing a taught toe line pulling the yacht to her death, it`s like been deliberately sunk.

    My guesse is that they were going at too much speed for the condition of sea causing the scuppers to fill the boat with water. But to allow the yacht to sink is unbelievably suspicious.

    That said more than one towline should have been applied or at best used a rope bridle arrangement with the one towline given that, a open stern deck allowed better access that yacht should never have been lost and allowed to sink as they looked on. Julian Mustoe must be looking at investigation and compensation here.

  • This is a terrible sad storry and I feel how this is devastating to Julian Mustoe. I have read this story now in different magazines and online forums.

    While terrible for the owner the fate of the Harrier leaves opens the discussion on emergency steering: “The entire stainless steel block had split into two pieces along the line of the rudder stock hole. Harrier’s rudder could not be used, it was now impossible to steer the yacht and no improvised repair was possible. I had to be towed back to harbour.”

    Julian Mustoe already circumnavigated and I wonder if an emergency steering system was in place? Perhaps it failed too? I seem to be able to make out a wind vane in the pictures. Could that not be used as an emergency steering? For exam the Monitor wind vane allows to attached a different blade to act an emergency steering.

    When we prepare for the Vic Maui Yacht the discussion around emergency steering is substantial. Every yacht is required to demonstrate the use of a suitable emergency steering.

    This opens another questions: The one of single handing offshore sailing. Installing the emergency steering can be and often is not an easy task, especially in rough weather and often requires team effort to be successful.

    I do wish for Julian Mustoe to get a new boat to live on. At the same time I hope that the loss of his beloved Harrier was not in vain and sparks a discussion about emergency steering and single handed offshore sailing.